What Will Diddy’s Sentence Be? Guns and Violence May Play a Role

Sean “Diddy” Combs was visibly elated when a jury cleared him of sex trafficking and racketeering charges in a Manhattan courtroom last July.

He slid from his chair to the floor at the defense table, kneeling as if in prayer, then rose to his feet, beaming.

“Love you! Love you! Love you!” the rap entrepreneur yelled, turning to face his cheering children and his sobbing mother. “I’m gonna be home soon!”

On Friday, he’ll find out if he can keep that promise.

Combs is set to be sentenced for what the jury did convict him of: two violations of the Mann Act, after jurors found he caused two girlfriends and at least eight male escorts to cross state lines for “freak offs” — the hotel sex sessions at the center of the trial.

In nearly 400 pages of pre-sentencing submissions, Combs’ lawyers and prosecutors from the US Attorney’s Office of the Southern District of New York made recommendations for the amount of time he should serve, and the gulf between the prosecution and defense teams’ numbers is enormous.

Combs’ lawyers are seeking a 14-month sentence — essentially time served — arguing that he has suffered enough during his past year in a Brooklyn federal jail and that he was acquitted of all serious misconduct.

The feds have asked for an 11-year sentence. Prosecutors want Combs behind bars for the next decade, arguing he remains a threat to society and left his two girlfriends “broken and beaten.”

Underlying this great divide is a single legal question: what weight will US District Judge Arun Subramanian give to Combs’ so-called “acquitted conduct.”

Put in less legal terms, what will the judge do with all the guns, drugs, and brutality the jury heard about — from dozens of witnesses — throughout Combs’ seven-week trial?

What weight to give ‘acquitted conduct’?

The defense concede in their pre-sentencing filings that, sure, the Bad Boy Records founder had drug problems.

And over the years, these drug problems spilled over into what they call “a domestic violence problem,” all of which, they argue, he regrets and is committed to never repeating.

Still, during sentencing, defense lawyers say, the judge must not consider acquitted conduct, including his violent conduct.

Combs was cleared of sex trafficking, his lawyers argue, because jurors found he was not someone who used force, fraud, or coercion to make his victims engage in commercial sex acts, as the law defines that crime.

The jury also found he was not a racketeer; they argue, rejecting the prosecution’s claim that he ran a criminal enterprise infested with violence, guns, drugs, and bribery to hide his wrongdoing.

“The jury’s verdict spoke loud and clear,” the defense wrote in pre-sentencing arguments. “To now increase Mr. Combs’s sentence based on evidence the jury rejected at trial would be to trivialize the jury’s work.”

Both Mann Act victims — R&B artist and star witness Cassie Ventura, Combs’ girlfriend from 2008 to 2018, and “Jane,” who testified under a pseudonym and dated Combs from 2021 to 2024 — told the jury they were brutally beaten by the powerful and wealthy hip-hop mogul.

But considering this acquitted conduct “would raise serious Sixth Amendment, Fifth Amendment, Double Jeopardy, and fairness concerns,” they wrote to Subramanian, foreshadowing a potential appeal on Constitutional grounds.

What if acquitted conduct is also ‘relevant conduct ‘?

In their own pre-sentencing submissions, federal prosecutors agree with the defense on one point.

They agree that ever since a rule change from November, acquitted conduct — in this case, guns, drugs, violence, and the like — can no longer count against a defendant in calculating sentencing-range recommendations for the judge.

(These calculations vary widely, based in large part on whether acquitted conduct is counted. Combs’ lawyers calculated a recommended sentencing range of six to 12 months. Probation’s range is 70 to 87 months. Federal prosecutors’ range is a hefty 360 months to life imprisonment.)

Still, that November rule change doesn’t tie the judge’s hands, prosecutors argue. Sentencing guidelines are only guidelines, they note. Judges can disregard them, and they often do.

Acquittals are not findings of fact, prosecutors also argue. Judges can’t know what happened in deliberations, and what evidence involving violence, drugs, or firearms the jury may have accepted or rejected.

Finally, prosecutors argue that there is ample caselaw that says a sentencing judge can consider acquitted conduct. The judge just needs to find said conduct relevant to the sentencing and proven at trial by a preponderance of the evidence — meaning that it was more likely true than not.

“Acquitted conduct can be considered where it establishes in whole or in part the offense of conviction,” prosecutors argued.

Combs’ punishment for those two Mann Act convictions “must take into account the manner in which he committed them,” prosecutors wrote the judge.

Subramanian — the judge — will likely demonstrate his own math at sentencing, revealing whether he took acquitted conduct into account or not.

Wild cards remain — including ‘Jane’ and some pro-Diddy escorts

Many more wild cards remain in Friday’s sentencing.

Combs’ lawyers have shared with the judge supporting comments from escorts who did not testify at trial, and who now say they were never paid for sex and saw no sign of violence. Their comments are sealed, as are defense submissions involving Combs’ mental health.

Several trial witnesses who had terrible experiences with Combs wrote letters urging Subramanian to bring down the hammer.

However, there is a glaring absence: “Jane,” one of the most important prosecution witnesses, who didn’t supply a letter, doesn’t plan to speak at the sentencing hearing, and isn’t seeking restitution.

She testified in June that Combs is paying the $10,000 rent for the Los Angeles home she shares with her young son; it is unclear if he continues to pay for her housing.

The defense and prosecution are fighting over whether another key sex-assault accuser, a former Combs employee who testified as “Mia,” will be allowed to give a victim impact statement. It remains unclear if the judge will allow her to speak.

Friday’s sentencing will also likely include public remarks by the trial’s two most pivotal witnesses: Ventura and Combs himself.

Ventura, in a letter to the judge on Tuesday, said she hoped Subramanian “considers the truths at hand that the jury failed to see” and imposes a sentence that “reflects the strength it took for victims of Sean Combs to come forward.”

“For over a decade, Sean Combs made me feel powerless and unimportant, but my experience was real, horrific, and deserves to be considered,” she wrote the judge in a letter made public Tuesday.

“While the jury did not seem to understand or believe that I engaged in freak offs because of the force and coercion the defendant used against me, I know that is the truth, and his sentence should reflect the reality of the evidence and my lived experience as a victim.”



Source link

Visited 1 times, 1 visit(s) today

Related Article

NATO F-35 Has New Kill Mark After Russian Drone Takedown

NATO F-35 Has New Kill Mark After Russian Drone Takedown

Dutch military photos showed an F-35 stealth fighter sporting a fresh drone-shaped kill mark after the advanced jet was used to shoot down Russian drones that violated alliance airspace. The images from the Netherlands’ defense ministry show the marking on the fuselage, just below the cockpit. The marking, not displayed on other F-35 fighter jets,

A helicopter flies overhead during an ICE raid in Chicago on early Tuesday morning.

ICE Barbie Ordered Midnight Raid From the Sky on Chicago

Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem has ICE agents literally raining from the sky. Videos show Black Hawk helicopters flying above Chicago, where NewsNation reports ICE agents rappelled out of choppers onto an apartment building’s rooftop during an overnight raid against alleged members of the Venezuelan gang Tren de Aragua. The massive action—carried out in the

Ian Coulter 'tried to hide payment from property deal', court told

Ian Coulter ‘tried to hide payment from property deal’, court told

Mark SimpsonCommunity correspondent, BBC News NI Pacemaker Mr Coulter, pictured outside court on Monday, denies five charges, including fraud and transferring criminal property A court has been told that the former head of a leading Belfast law firm tried to hide a multi-million-pound payment which was received from Northern Ireland’s biggest property deal. Ian Coulter,

btc net inflow

Is BTC Price on Track to Reclaim Its All-Time High?

Leading digital asset Bitcoin is up 3% today, driven by renewed optimism across the broader crypto market. The rally comes as the US government shutdown weighs on the dollar, prompting significantly higher inflows into BTC over the past day. With buy-side pressure strengthening, the king coin could be on its way to reclaiming its all-time

AFAD said the tremor centered in the Marmara Sea, southwest of Istanbul, along a faultline long seen as a risk for the city of 16 million people.(Reuters/Representational Image)

Earthquake of magnitude 5.0 hits Turkey’s Istanbul

Published on: Oct 02, 2025 06:10 pm IST An earthquake of magnitude 5.0 hit Turkey’s Istanbul. The tremor centered in the Marmara Sea A 5.0-magnitude earthquake rattled buildings in Turkey’s largest city Istanbul on Thursday, sending some people rushing out to the streets, Reuters witnesses and the AFAD disaster agency said. AFAD said the tremor

Israeli Navy vessels escort one of the boats from the civilian Gaza-bound flotilla Sumud after it was intercepted approaching the Gaza coast, toward the port of Ashdod.(AP)

What happens to Gaza flotilla activists detained by Israel?

Israeli forces have intercepted boats carrying aid bound for Gaza, in the latest attempt by foreign activists to break an Israeli blockade and deliver supplies to the Palestinian territory. Israeli Navy vessels escort one of the boats from the civilian Gaza-bound flotilla Sumud after it was intercepted approaching the Gaza coast, toward the port of

Israel says will deport aid flotilla activists – DW – 10/02/2025

Skip next section South African President calls for release of flotilla activists 10/02/2025October 2, 2025 South African President calls for release of flotilla activists South African President Cyril Ramaphosa has called on Israel to release any of his country’s nationals who were detained on the humanitarian vessels that were part of the Global Sumud Flotilla en route