Trump’s peace plan comes with some major sticking points

Israel and Hamas may have agreed to the first phase of President Donald Trump’s peace plan, but major hurdles remain to permanently end the hostilities that have caused chaos, death and devastation for more than two years in the region.

Several elements of the president’s multipronged road map conflict with Hamas’ interests, including a call for the U.S.-designated terrorist group to disarm and for Gaza to be temporarily governed by a Trump-led council of nations. There’s also questions about the structure and logistics of an international peacekeeping force that would be deployed to Gaza.

“We have to be careful to constantly sort out what has been achieved,” former U.S. deputy national security adviser Ben Rhodes told MSNBC.

He added that there were “key areas of differences” between the two parties.

“If those are not addressed, we could be sitting here in a couple of months with Israeli military operations resumed in the Gaza Strip,” Rhodes said.

The initial step of Trump’s 20-point blueprint — a hostage-and-prisoner exchange set to begin early next week — comes with its own challenges. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s government finalized a list of Palestinian prisoners set to be released, which could include individuals accused of orchestrating major terrorist attacks. That’s a significant point of political tension in Israel.

Lianne Pollak-David, a former adviser to Netanyahu who served as a negotiator to Israel’s Palestinian counterparts, noted that Hamas has a history of playing “tricks” in past hostage releases, including sending the wrong dead body to relatives. “If something of that sort goes wrong, that could blow up the whole thing, the whole deal,” she said.

But Trump’s expected travel to the Middle East on Sunday, with visits to Israel and Egypt, could put pressure on both sides to uphold their ends of the bargain. A stop in Gaza was initially considered, but ultimately ruled out, said a White House official, who stressed that the president’s travel plans remain fluid and subject to change. Trump’s presence in the region, shortly before hostages are expected to be released, “brings a certain gravitas to the process,” Pollak-David said.

Here’s a deeper look at some of the key sticking points to watch in the White House’s peace plan:

Disarmament of Hamas

Leaders of Hamas have previously said they would be unwilling to disarm during the course of negotiations with meditators that have stretched on for more than a year. However, a senior U.S. administration official downplayed concerns about disarmament, arguing that private communications don’t match up with those public statements.

Hugh Lovatt, an analyst at the European Council on Foreign Relations, believes members of the political wing of Hamas — who are mostly based in Qatar — are open to surrendering offensive weapons. Such actions could include destroying missiles, production facilities and underground attack tunnels.

“Hamas has stuck quite hard to many of its red lines, but on the question of decommissioning, to use their words, that is something where there has been the most notable shifts,” Lovatt said.

But Lovatt also stressed that much is still unknown in terms of implementation.

‘Board of Peace’

Governance of Gaza remains a complex and politically charged issue. Israel is opposed to a governing structure that consists of only Palestinians, while Palestinians are ultimately looking for self-determination.

In Trump’s proposal, the administration describes a temporary apolitical committee of “qualified Palestinians and international experts.” A council of foreign leaders — one that includes former British prime minister Tony Blair and is chaired by Trump — would then oversee the committee.

Trump’s role at the helm, according to Lovatt, is seen as a positive by some Arab countries, suggesting that the White House has a longer-term stake in remaining involved in the process.

“The idea of an international oversight committee is a way of trying to square that circle between Israeli demands and Palestinian expectations,” Lovatt said. “If the board has sweeping powers over Gaza’s legislation, judiciary, real estate, then that’s a problem. If it’s more of a supervisory capacity, then that’s much more in line with Palestinian demands.”

International Stabilization Force

U.S. Central Command — more colloquially known as CENTCOM — is leading a joint task force of armed forces from various countries, including up to 200 American personnel who will be responsible for ensuring that phase one is completed without violations of the agreement.

Egypt, Qatar, Turkey and the United Arab Emirates also would provide armed forces to be embedded in the group. It’s possible some of those U.S. personnel could be on the ground in Israel, according to a White House official. But the personnel are not “intended” to enter Gaza, another official said.

Ultimately, Trump’s framework aims for an international peacekeeping force to be established to replace Israel’s troops in Gaza. Discussions continue with multiple governments on the force’s creation, according to senior administration officials.

Those talks could address open questions about funding and the logistics of the force. But a well-defined mandate of the force remains a bigger question. And whether the force would simply be involved in deconfliction, or whether counterterrorism and intelligence efforts also would be part of the force’s mission, remains to be seen.

Lovett said the risk is that any international force gets stuck in Gaza without a clear timeline for a two-state solution. That lack of clarity, Lovatt added, is perhaps the most significant challenge ahead for all parties involved.

“The U.S. effort is not really dealing with the root causes, which is Israeli political, public opposition to a two-state solution” and “a very dysfunctional Palestinian political landscape,” Lovatt said.

“At best case, it’s a stepping-stone or two towards that,” he said.

Source link

Visited 1 times, 1 visit(s) today

Related Article

A massive fire broke out at the Dhaka airport on Saturday.(PTI)

Bangladesh: Massive fire near Dhaka airport, flight operations suspended | Video

Updated on: Oct 18, 2025 04:57 pm IST A video showed thick clouds of smoke engulfing the airport as the blaze continued in the cargo village area. A massive fire broke out at Dhaka’s Hazrat Shahjalal International Airport in the Bangladesh capital on Saturday afternoon, which prompted the authorities to suspend flight operations. A massive

'That's an easy one…': Trump predicts 'success' with Pakistan-Afghanistan war, says he has saved millions of lives - World News

‘That’s an easy one…’: Trump predicts ‘success’ with Pakistan-Afghanistan war, says he has saved millions of lives – World News

US President Donald Trump is no stranger to ‘ending’ international wars — having claimed credit for singlehandedly averting multiple global crises over the past year. The POTUS has now insisted that he could “easily” solve the ongoing Pakistan-Afghanistan ‘if’ he chose to intervene. “I do understand Pakistan attacked or there is an attack going on

Last year, 1,997 Indians were subject for forced removals by Canadian authorities, trailing only 3,683 Mexicans and far over the third largest cohort, 981 Colombians. (REUTERS)

Record number of Indians deported from Canada between Jan and Oct 2025

The number of Indian nationals forcibly removed from Canada this year is on track to surpass the record number that was logged in 2024. Last year, 1,997 Indians were subject for forced removals by Canadian authorities, trailing only 3,683 Mexicans and far over the third largest cohort, 981 Colombians. (REUTERS) Last year, 1,997 Indians were

A Ukrainian soldier crouches with a remote next to a quadcopter used to destroy other drones.

Ukraine’s cheap interceptor drones are rewriting the rules of war

About a year into Russia’s war, a Ukrainian drone instructor pitched what sounded to troops like science fiction: flying quadcopters into Moscow’s scout drones midair. The soldiers thought it was impossible. It would be too difficult to maneuver a quadcopter, or small drone, into another fast-moving target, they said. They joked that he’d been watching

President Donald Trump pictured speaking to reporters after arriving in West Palm Beach, Florida, on Friday.

Trump denies Ukraine Tomahawk missiles, urges both sides to ‘stop the war immediately’

Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky failed to obtain Tomahawk missiles for strikes on Russia from a meeting with Donald Trump on Friday, with the US president later calling for both sides to cease fighting and accept current battle lines. Zelensky had traveled to Washington hoping to receive the long-range cruise missiles, which he believes could deliver

The Taliban government's statement comes even as peace talks are set to begin in Doha. (Reuters)

Afghanistan’s Taliban ‘reserves right to respond’ to Pakistani airstrikes

Even as Pakistan and Afghanistan gear up to meet in Doha today to broker a peace after days of fighting and air strike the Taliban Government said that Afghanistan reserves the right to respond to Pakistani airstrikes on its land. The Taliban government’s statement comes even as peace talks are set to begin in Doha.