Should congressional leaders be able to trade stocks? – Deseret News


Members of Congress were active in the stock market last year, disclosing 11,000 transactions tallying up to over $1 billion.

Now — in the attitude of, if you can’t beat them, join them — websites and social media accounts are watching the financial moves of these elected officials and helping Americans trade like members of Congress.

A report, produced by Unusual Whales, a platform that tracks congressional trading, found evidence of conflicts of interest in many cases of congressional trending. This trend is fairly widespread in both the House and the Senate.

Sen. Tommy Tuberville, one of the most active traders in Congress, is on the Senate Committee for Agriculture, Nutrition and Forestry. He traded $250,000 in stocks for wheat, corn, soy and cattle in August, last year, the report stated. He also sits on the Armed Services Committee and has purchased shares of a company used to provide humanitarian aid in Ukraine.

In the lower chamber, Rep. Nancy Pelosi and her husband, Paul, a venture capitalist, bought $2 million worth of Nvidia stock, at the end of 2023, marking her largest stock purchase in three years. They have already made over $1 million in profit, according to Nasdaq. The AI software company produces semiconductor chips and saw 239% stock growth in 2023.

Pelosi’s moves on the stock market are closely monitored on the internet, with investors, big and small, trying to replicate her success. Scalping data from financial disclosures, many websites, like Capitol Trades and Quiver Quant, and social media accounts, like Congress Stock Watcher, Unusual Whales, Insider Tracker and many others, have popped up to provide inside information on the stocks she and other lawmakers buy. There are, of course, always risks whenever one buys and sells stocks.

One Reddit post from four months ago says, “Want to beat the stock market? Just copy Congress! Politicians’ trades perform twice as well as market average.” These tools have put the financial moves made by congressional leaders under a microscope.

But when elected officials have financial interests tied to their legislative work, it raises ethical concerns: Are they acting in the public’s best interest or for their personal gain?

“It raises a lot of questions. Why did they introduce a bill? Why did they support it?” said Danielle Caputo, the legal counsel on ethics at the Campaign Legal Center, an advocate for stricter accountability standards on stock trading in Congress. A 2022 report from Caputo’s watchdog organization found that over half the members of Congress owned stock.

In 2021, back when Pelosi was speaker of the House, she defended a lawmaker’s right to trade stocks, saying, “This is a free market.”

“We have a responsibility to report,” Pelosi said, according to The Associated Press. “If people aren’t reporting, they should be.”

Right now, a 2012 law, the Stock Act, is the only legislation guiding stock purchases among lawmakers and staffers.

But “depending on what level of seniority you are as a staff member, (and) what committee you’re on, you can trade stuff based on committees,” said Caputo.

She doesn’t think the law goes far enough. “Essentially, the act is a transparency bill,” said Caputo, referring to the provision that requires members to report their trades within 45 days of the transaction and a penalty of $200 for breaking the rule. “Let’s say you make a million dollars off of that trade, a $200 fine isn’t going to dissuade you from making that choice in any way.”

A 2021 Business Insider investigation showed that 78 lawmakers failed to report their trades, as mandated by law.

Plus, chasing insider trading allegations can be a complex process, as Robert Long, a former senior attorney at the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, told Vox in March 2020.

“The line between illegal trading and innocuous trading is not bright — it’s often a murky line,” said Long. “Subtle facts and legal issues can make the difference between having an insider trading investigation closed and being prosecuted and going to jail.”

Alabama Sen. Tommy Tuberville holds up a pocket copy of the Declaration of Independence as he endorses Riverton Mayor Trent Staggs in his U.S. Senate run during an election event in Layton at Faith Baptist Church on Friday, March 15, 2024. | Scott G Winterton, Deseret News

Pelosi’s initial move on Nvidia prompted Sen. Josh Hawley of Missouri to introduce the Preventing Elected Leaders from Owning Securities and Investments Act, also known as the PELOSI Act, in January 2023.

“While Wall Street and Big Tech work hand-in-hand with elected officials to enrich each other, hard-working Americans pay the price,” said Hawley, a Republican. “The solution is clear: we must immediately and permanently ban all members of Congress from trading stocks.”

On Thursday, Rep. Ro Khanna, D-Calif., in a post on X laid out his five-point anti-corruption plan to tackle “the role of Big Money in the halls of Congress.” This plan includes a ban on stock trading. Unusual Whales in its 2023 report said Khanna disclosed his family initiatied more than 1,500 transactions in industries like healthcare, financial services, technology, defense and real estate.

He was among the top stock sellers last year and is up for reelection this year. Khanna sits on the House Armed Services and House Oversight and Accountability committees.

Rep. Matt Gaetz, R-Fla., and Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, D-N.Y., two elected officials from different ends of the political spectrum, joined forces to carve out the Bipartisan Restoring Faith in Government Act, which would prevent lawmakers and their families from investing in securities, like stocks, bonds or commodities, including oil or gold.

Shortly after becoming the speaker, Rep. Mike Johnson, R-La., received a letter from Virginia Democrat Rep. Abigail Spanberger in October, urging him to ban congressional members from stock trading, but, as Roll Call reported, she never received a response. It’s worth noting, Johnson has not reported any trade activity in the last three years.

According to a survey by the Program for Public Consultation, 86% of House and Senate members say they favor prohibiting stock-trading in individual companies by congressional lawmakers as well as the president, vice president, and Supreme Court justices.

The support for such a ban is strong among American voters, too, with roughly 68% in favor, according to a 2022 national poll from Morning Consult/ Politico.

Watchdogs say any proposed legislation should also ban investing in private equities and digital currency like Bitcoin, to ensure funds aren’t going to venues offering less transparency. Instead of forcing members of Congress to disinvest, they can put them into a qualified blind trust.

“That would still allow them to make money off of investments but they would just not know what their investments are,” said Caputo.

When asked if such prohibitions discourage those from business backgrounds from running for office, Caputo simply stated, “public office isn’t an entitlement, it’s a privilege.”

Other countries have laws limiting lawmakers from stock trading. Canada’s Conflict of Interest Act draws a line between private interests and the public duties of appointed officials. In the U.K., the parliamentary code of conduct prevents members from advocating for a particular company for personal gain. Australia doesn’t ban stock trading, but its members of parliament are legally bound to disclose any trades within 28 days.

“We’re hoping we’ll still be able to effectuate a change,” said Caputo. “I don’t think it’s a lost hope … I do think that we’re very close to having some sort of restriction or ban on members of Congress trading stock.”





Source link

Visited 1 times, 1 visit(s) today

Related Article

Vote on Trump’s ‘big, beautiful bill’ underway: ‘Vote-a-rama’ becomes longest in Senate history - What is Vote-a-rama? | Explained

Trump’s ‘big, beautiful bill’ faces Senate’s longest vote in history; DOGE could probe Musk, and more

The United States Senate has entered the longest vote-a-rama in its history as lawmakers debate President Donald Trump’s sweeping tax and spending package, officially titled the ‘One Big Beautiful Bill.’ President Donald Trump has suggested that immigration authorities could be directed to investigate Elon Musk after the billionaire renewed his criticism of the administration’s flagship

Newcastle are exploring a move for Marseille centre back Leonardo Balerdi (left)

TRANSFER CONFIDENTIAL: Newcastle’s three new targets as they rival Spurs for Premier League star, Eberechi Eze’s favoured club emerges and Man City battle Liverpool for EFL wonderkid

NEWCASTLE UNITED are exploring a move for MARSEILLE centre back Leonardo Balerdi. The 26-year-old Argentina international has been impressing under Roberto De Zerbi and has drawn enquiries from Juventus in recent weeks, having worked previously with their coach Igor Tudor at Marseille. However, with Juventus juggling a number of targets and their budget limited, Newcastle

Republicans ignore debt worry as they push forward on Trump tax-cut bill

By David Morgan, Bo Erickson and Davide Barbuscia WASHINGTON (Reuters) -As President Donald Trump’s Republicans push ahead on a sweeping tax-cut and spending bill that nonpartisan analysts say could add $3.3 trillion to the nation’s debt over the next decade, they’re taking a new approach – denying there is anything to worry about. Instead, they

MSFT's Sentiment Meter and Message Volume as of 10.15 a.m. ET on July 1, 2025 | Source: Stocktwits

Microsoft Strikes 5-Year Deal With Premier League To Bring AI-Powered Experience To Global Fans

The Premier League partners with Microsoft in a five-year deal to upgrade digital platforms, using AI and cloud tools to enhance fan engagement. Premier League and Microsoft Corp. (MSFT) have signed a five‑year deal to revamp how roughly 1.8 billion supporters across 189 countries interact with the league’s digital ecosystem.  The partnership positions Microsoft as the

A video clip circulating online appears to show the victim on the slope while other climbers looked on. Photo: Weibo / 困困小羊羔-

Hong Kong teen dies on 5,276-metre peak in Sichuan province

Hong Kong’s Immigration Department is assisting the family of a 16-year-old resident who reportedly died while climbing a snow-covered mountain in Sichuan province in mainland China. An image circulating online believed to show an official bulletin from the Mount Siguniang Scenic Area Administration said the victim was a Hong Kong resident living in Shenzhen in

Eat, Try, Love: Rugby Premier League’s Indian summer needs to be built upon

After a lot of cracking action, and an out-of-character hilariously one-sided final, the inaugural Rugby Premier League is done. From following the action closely, and talking to those involved, here’s what we learned from the last fortnight: Editor’s Picks 2 Related The world’s best bring their A-game, India’s best step up In July 2024, Joseva

No Time To Learn About Stocks? Follow Warren Buffett’s 6 Top Tips Instead

If you’ve ever wanted to invest in stocks but have been too overwhelmed, you’re not alone. In fact, you’re probably in the majority, especially during this time of economic volatility. Between Trump’s tariffs, rumored recessions and unpredictable government spending, you may think that learning about the stock market isn’t a good investment for your time.

0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x