Opinion | Even in the West, the era of consequence-free expression is over

Charlie Kirk’s death in the United States was a major political shock. But what followed was more revealing: employees disciplined for social media posts, celebrities facing backlash for controversial remarks and businesses scrambling to distance themselves from the fallout. The controversy highlighted a broader truth of the digital age: a single comment, whether in jest or in earnest, can escalate into a crisis.

In today’s hyperconnected world, words travel instantly, reach audiences well beyond their original context and often persist online forever. One remark can ignite a controversy, prompting employers, universities and regulators to respond swiftly.

For companies and institutions, this situation is daunting. The risk is no longer limited to their official policies, but also extends to the unpredictable actions of staff or affiliates, whose online comments can have legal, financial and social repercussions. Leaders often find themselves caught between safeguarding their reputation and addressing political or consumer outrage, which becomes increasingly challenging.

The aftermath of Kirk’s killing highlighted these tensions. Dozens of people were suspended or dismissed for remarks deemed offensive. Late-night TV host Jimmy Kimmel was briefly taken off the air after criticising public reactions and accusing politicians of exploiting the tragedy. His comments, in turn, prompted regulatory scrutiny and reignited debate about where to draw the line between free expression and responsible speech. Some warned of increasing government overreach, while others argued that unchecked rhetoric was causing harm.
This pattern is becoming a global phenomenon. In Britain, debates over immigration and identity have sharpened into polarising cultural battles. Across Europe and elsewhere, the war in Gaza has sparked protests and left governments struggling to balance public order with the right to dissent. In such climates, many now fear speaking openly on race, migration or the Middle East, wary that one misjudged phrase will unleash severe professional or political consequences.
Yet these pressures are not new. Hong Kong experienced similar issues years earlier. In 2012, a crowdfunded Apple Daily ad infamously branded mainland visitors as locusts, fuelling days of protest and setting the tone for confrontations in malls, trains and online spaces. At the same time, criticism of parallel traders became a proxy for local grievances and, at times, outright xenophobia.
A Hong Kong newspaper with an anti-mainland Chinese advertisement with a picture of a locust looming over the Hong Kong cityscape as mainlanders pose for a picture in the background on February 1, 2012. Photo: AFP
A Hong Kong newspaper with an anti-mainland Chinese advertisement with a picture of a locust looming over the Hong Kong cityscape as mainlanders pose for a picture in the background on February 1, 2012. Photo: AFP

Source link

Visited 1 times, 1 visit(s) today

Related Article

Hong Kong police confident National Games will go off without a hitch

Hong Kong police confident National Games will go off without a hitch

Hong Kong police say they are armed with enough personnel and resources, including 600 drones and 200 trained dogs, to ensure the coming National Games go off without a hitch. And while there was no specific intelligence suggesting terrorists would target the city during the Games, contingency plans were in place to deal with emergent

From Stephen Chow films to Beyond hits: PLA sailors share Hong Kong affinity

From Stephen Chow films to Beyond hits: PLA sailors share Hong Kong affinity

Sailors from two visiting PLA naval vessels have shown their softer side by sharing their experiences touring Hong Kong during the National Day celebrations and revealing how the city’s pop culture has influenced them. Thousands of residents also headed to Stonecutters Island to board the training vessel Qi Jiguang and amphibious assault ship Yimeng Shan

Hong Kong’s retail recovery accelerates as August sales rise by 3.8%

Hong Kong’s retail recovery accelerates as August sales rise by 3.8%

Hong Kong’s retail recovery accelerated in August with sales rising by 3.8 per cent year on year and for the fourth month in a row, as the city’s mega-event tourism drive provided a boost to consumer sentiment. Provisional figures released by the Census and Statistics Department on Thursday showed sales of HK$30.3 billion (US$3.9 billion)

Mainland Chinese tourists in Hong Kong head for Cheung Chau to avoid crowds

Mainland Chinese tourists in Hong Kong head for Cheung Chau to avoid crowds

Hong Kong’s Cheung Chau has emerged as a quiet haven for mainland Chinese visitors who want to avoid the city’s crowded urban neighbourhoods during the National Day holidays. Hundreds of tourists headed to the outlying island on Thursday morning, the second day of the mainland’s “golden week” break. They were among the 1.5 million visitors

Singapore stablecoin issuer offers tips for Hong Kong counterparts

Singapore stablecoin issuer offers tips for Hong Kong counterparts

The issuer of XSGD – the only Singapore dollar-backed stablecoin and one of the world’s major non-US dollar stablecoins – said its commitment to strict regulatory compliance and emphasis on cross-border payments could serve as a model for stablecoin issuers in Hong Kong. In an interview with the South China Morning Post on Thursday in

Hong Kong shelves HK$700 million infrastructure gallery proposal after backlash

Hong Kong shelves HK$700 million infrastructure gallery proposal after backlash

Hong Kong authorities have shelved a controversial proposal to build a costly exhibition hall at a prime site to showcase major development projects, including the Northern Metropolis. The construction of the HK$700 million (US$90 million) gallery on the Wan Chai North waterfront was first announced in the 2023 policy address. The budget was included in

Hong Kong may issue No 1 typhoon signal on Friday night as Tropical Storm Matmo nears

Hong Kong may issue No 1 typhoon signal on Friday night as Tropical Storm Matmo nears

This story has been made freely available as a public service to our readers. Please consider supporting SCMP’s journalism by subscribing. Hong Kong’s weather forecaster will consider issuing the No 1 typhoon warning signal on Friday night as a tropical storm moves across the Philippines and enters the South China Sea. The Hong Kong Observatory