Legal Tales | A brief history of pupil barristers and the system’s evolution in Hong Kong

On the first day of my pupillage in September 1999, my “pupil master” showed me around his chambers and introduced me to various members. Not being alive to our customs and traditions, I put my hand out expecting a firm handshake with a senior member but was told: “You are now a member of the Bar and we do not shake hands with each other.”

It was then explained to me that the tradition was rooted in the sword-bearing era, when a handshake signalled no hostile intent and was unnecessary for a gentleman’s profession.

What followed for me was 12 months as “the lowest form of legal life”, which was most enjoyable and challenging.

It was challenging for me to discover how little I knew, but it was probably more challenging for my pupil masters, who had to deal with the shock of discovering how little I knew. One of them commented that it was easier to teach a piece of char siu (Cantonese barbecue pork) than to teach me. I am still not entirely sure it was meant to be a joke, but I have convinced myself that it was.

The routine of being cross-examined by them on my work and my inability to come up with anything coherent in response continued for the next 12 months.

To my horror, that began to happen again a few years later when one of my pupil masters joined the bench (i.e. became a judge). My inability to deal with questions from him has become a recurring feature of my day-to-day life when appearing before him in court.

Source link

Visited 1 times, 1 visit(s) today

Related Article

Hong Kong buildings swaying in Super Typhoon Ragasa ‘nothing to worry about’

Hong Kong buildings swaying in Super Typhoon Ragasa ‘nothing to worry about’

As Super Typhoon Ragasa battered Hong Kong with hurricane-strength winds on Wednesday morning, some worried residents felt their high-rise buildings sway, but experts and authorities have assured the public that such movements are normal. Ragasa, which triggered the highest-level No 10 warning signal, came within about 100km to the south of Hong Kong in the

Severe Typhoon Ragasa: Hong Kong’s coastal, low-lying areas hit by floodwaters

Severe Typhoon Ragasa: Hong Kong’s coastal, low-lying areas hit by floodwaters

Coastal and low-lying areas across Hong Kong have been hit hard by Severe Typhoon Ragasa, as it brought a significant storm surge and rainstorms to the city, inundating streets and promenades. Widespread flooding could be seen across the city on Wednesday morning, with the Hong Kong Observatory reporting that water levels in some areas had

McDonald’s, cha chaan teng defy Ragasa to feed hungry Hongkongers

McDonald’s, cha chaan teng defy Ragasa to feed hungry Hongkongers

As Super Typhoon Ragasa pummelled Hong Kong on Wednesday, some brave restaurants kept their doors open for hungry Hongkongers. Despite the Hong Kong Observatory maintaining its highest-level No 10 warning in the morning for the year’s most powerful storm, before lowering it to No 8 at lunchtime, many residents braved gale-force winds and heavy downpours

Opinion | How AI can catalyse Hong Kong’s next big economic take-off

Opinion | How AI can catalyse Hong Kong’s next big economic take-off

Hong Kong’s economic story has always unfolded in cycles of innovation. Finance made it a global hub. Real estate later became a backbone. Both engines now face structural limits. As global competition intensifies, the question is what Hong Kong’s new growth engine will be. The policy address offers a clear signal: artificial intelligence (AI) is

Ragasa wreaks havoc in Hong Kong, with Ocean Park hotel breached by waves, ship grounded

Ragasa wreaks havoc in Hong Kong, with Ocean Park hotel breached by waves, ship grounded

Super Typhoon Ragasa wreaked havoc across Hong Kong on Wednesday, with strong waves shattering the glass doors of an Ocean Park hotel, and violent winds blowing a barge ashore and tearing air conditioning units from homes. Dubbed the “king of storms” by mainland weather authorities, Ragasa maintained winds of 220km/h (137mph) near its centre when

Hong Kong bankers pack luxury hotels near offices for typhoon trading

Hong Kong bankers pack luxury hotels near offices for typhoon trading

Hong Kong’s bankers and traders hunkered down at home or booked hotels near their offices as Super Typhoon Ragasa descended on the Asian financial hub. The big international banks, including Goldman Sachs, Morgan Stanley and HSBC Holdings, told most employees to work from home before the typhoon unleashed a deluge of rain and sustained winds