Latest US-China Trade Truce Leaves Fundamental Issues Unresolved

<p>Shipping at the Port of Nansha in Guangzhou, China.</p>

Shipping at the Port of Nansha in Guangzhou, China.

Chinese and US trade negotiators have lined up an array of diplomatic wins for Donald Trump and Xi Jinping to unveil at a summit this week. Those easy hits are pleasing investors, but leave deeper core conflicts unresolved.

Most Read from Bloomberg

President Donald Trump told reporters on Monday that “I really feel good” about a deal with China, after officials this weekend in Malaysia unveiled a slew of agreements to ease trade tensions. That’ll likely see China resume soy purchases in key Republican voting states, while America walks back its latest 100% tariff threat in exchange for securing Beijing’s critical rare-earth magnets.

Markets rallied on the news with the MSCI’s index for global stocks testing all-time highs, but analysts cautioned the deal now teed up for Trump and Xi to sign in South Korea ignored thorny issues. Fundamental fights over national security appeared untouched, they said, along with Trump’s stated core mission of rebalancing trade. Making that harder, Chinese investment into America remains heavily restricted.

WATCH: Top trade negotiators for the US and China have said they came to terms on a range of contentious points, setting the table for leaders Donald Trump and Xi Jinping to finalize a deal.Source: Bloomberg
WATCH: Top trade negotiators for the US and China have said they came to terms on a range of contentious points, setting the table for leaders Donald Trump and Xi Jinping to finalize a deal.Source: Bloomberg

“Picking the low-hanging fruit makes the path ahead inherently tougher because it leaves the hard, high-stakes conflicts for last,” said Sun Chenghao, a fellow at Tsinghua University in Beijing. “The ‘grand deal’ requires tackling profound disagreements on state subsidies, tech competition and national security — areas where both sides’ fundamental models clash.”

That means a series of smaller, sectoral agreements achieved through sustained dialogue are more likely over the coming years, he added.

US Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent has been pushing China to rebalance its economy and get the domestic consumer spending more during recent trade talks. Beijing appeared to ignore those calls last week, unveiling a policy document that emphasized manufacturing and tech self-sufficiency as the driving forces of the Chinese economy until at least 2030.

The contours of the China deal emerged as Trump began his weeklong trip to Asia by clinching trade pacts with Thailand and Malaysia touching on rare earths, and pledges to combat anti-dumping with Cambodia — all areas of contention with China. The Republican’s rallying of American allies in Beijing’s backyard appeared designed to build leverage ahead of his first sit down with Xi since returning to power.

Underscoring the importance of leader-to-leader dialogue, Trump reiterated his pledge to visit China and suggested Xi could come to Washington or Mar-a-Lago, his private club in Florida. China is hosting the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation forum in 2026, while the US will hold the Group of Twenty leaders’ summit, giving both a reason to visit each other’s nations.

Explainer: How the US-China Trade War Has Flared Up Again

Ever since Trump made China the top target of America’s steepest tariff regime since the 1930s, bilateral ties have lurched between tit-for-tat escalation and economic talks to bring down the temperature.

The Chinese Communist Party’s official mouthpiece on Monday urged the world’s biggest economies to avoid lapsing back into that cycle, appealing for efforts to “jointly safeguard the hard-won achievements” from their latest talks.

That commentary called on the US to stick the consultation mechanism led by Bessent and Chinese Vice Premier He Lifeng. Export curbs announced by US officials outside that framework have destabilized ties several times, prompting Beijing to jam its supply of rare earth critical to American manufacturing.

“Both sides now seem to be focused primarily on stability,” Daniel Kritenbrink, partner at The Asia Group and former US assistant secretary of state for East Asian and Pacific affairs, told Bloomberg Television. “But none of the fundamentals in this relationship have changed.”

WATCH: “The China Show” featuring Daniel Kritenbrink.Source: Bloomberg
WATCH: “The China Show” featuring Daniel Kritenbrink.Source: Bloomberg

While Bessent said he believed China would delay its latest rare-earth restrictions “for a year while they reexamine it” after the latest talks, friction over export controls remains. Chinese officials have used their chokehold over magnets needed to make everything from mobile phones to missiles to push back against US curbs on cutting-edge chips. Washington says those measures are necessary to restrain China’s military ambitions.

It had been unclear, however, how Beijing would logistically enforce curbs asserting control over any global shipment containing even a trace of certain rare metals from China, a move that had sparked outcry in Europe, too.

China unveiled its latest measures in retaliation to the US expanding its own sanctions list to include thousands more Chinese companies. With Bessent saying that rolling back US export controls was off the table, a key question is what Xi gets in return for the pause other then reducing the threat of higher tariffs — and how long the delay will remain in place.

“China’s never going to give up its leverage on rare earths,” said Dexter Roberts, a nonresident senior fellow at the Atlantic Council’s Global China Hub. “That would be sheer stupidity on their part.”

One area where US officials signaled progress was fentanyl, raising the prospect a 20% tariff Trump imposed to pressure Beijing into halting the flow of chemicals used to make the deadly drug could be lowered. Relief on that levy — which stacks on top of Liberation Day tariffs — could be a boon for the Asian nation at a time when domestic demand is weak.

Other major issues such as an investigation into China’s implementation of the “Phase One” agreement from the first trade war appear unresolved, although Trump on Monday suggested he could drop that probe, if things work out well.

Ultimately, the deal signaled amounted to a mix of small issues, said Scott Kennedy, senior adviser at the Center for Strategic and International Studies in Washington, noting Beijing’s industrial policy seemingly wasn’t up for discussion.

“They’ve kicked the can to the side and are focusing on very concrete, narrow issues, putting aside broader questions about China’s economic system and economic security,” he added. “It’s highly unlikely they’ll ever address those broader issues head on.”

–With assistance from Philip J. Heijmans, Allen Wan, David Ingles and Yvonne Man.

Most Read from Bloomberg Businessweek

©2025 Bloomberg L.P.

Source link

Visited 1 times, 1 visit(s) today

Related Article

A chart showing the countries of origin of top AI researchers at US institutions.

Nvidia’s Huang defends China tech talent at DC conference

While the tug of war between the US and China over chips has been well covered, Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang raised another group caught in the crossfire that has received less attention in Washington: Chinese tech talent. At the company’s annual developers confab, held in the US capital for the first time this week, Huang

Trump raising a glass of champagne

Trump touts ‘trillions’ from Asia trip ahead of Xi Jinping meeting

NEWYou can now listen to Fox News articles! President Donald Trump still has a major meeting on the agenda, but he’s already touting the success of his tour in Asia, saying it returned “trillions” to the U.S. “Bringing back trillions of Dollars to USA! A great trip. Dealing with very smart, talented, and wonderful leaders,”

Relief – and caution – as China resumes US soybean purchases

Relief – and caution – as China resumes US soybean purchases

American soybean farmers got some rare good news on Wednesday just hours before a high-stakes meeting between Chinese President Xi Jinping and US President Donald Trump when news broke that Beijing had placed its first order after months of trade tension that saw shipments blocked. The Trump administration hailed the move as a “positive step

An aerial view of the Port of Bandar Abbas in the strait of Hormuz, December 10, 2023.

Western intelligence says Iran is rearming despite UN sanctions, with China’s help

Iran appears to be stepping up the rebuilding of its ballistic missile program, despite the reintroduction last month of United Nations sanctions that ban arms sales to the country and ballistic missile activity. European intelligence sources say several shipments of sodium perchlorate, the main precursor in the production of the solid propellant that powers Iran’s

American lawmakers told US must learn from China to revive shipbuilding

American lawmakers told US must learn from China to revive shipbuilding

If the US hopes to rebuild a competitive shipbuilding industry and narrow China’s commanding lead, it should adopt some lessons from Beijing – emphasising long-term planning, steady government funding and policy consistency, witnesses told a US Senate hearing this week. China’s phenomenal rise in the global shipbuilding sector has caught the attention of Washington’s policymakers