Jane Street case: Shankar Sharma raises concerns over exchanges’ oversight

Veteran investor Shankar Sharma has raised sharp questions about the role of Indian stock exchanges in the recent Jane Street controversy, suggesting that profit motives may have prevented timely action against the global trading firm.

In a post on X (formerly Twitter), Sharma questioned why the exchanges did not act sooner against Jane Street, even though they are among the first to receive trading alerts.

“How come the stock exchanges never sanctioned Jane Street? They are the very first to get such alerts,” Sharma wrote. “How can they sanction JS when it drives F&O volume massively, hence SE profits?”

‘Exchanges are not meant to chase profits’

Sharma, who has often criticised the structure of listed exchanges, renewed his call for a rethink of their role. According to him, exchanges function as quasi-regulators and should operate like public utilities — not profit-driven corporations.“I have long held that exchanges should NEVER get listed. They are a regulator. Profit motive creates endless conflict of interest,” he wrote. “SEs should be a utility, not for-profits. Simple as that. Nahi to, suffer all this hanky-panky.”

Sebi vs Jane Street

On Friday, the Securities and Exchange Board of India (Sebi) passed an interim order accusing Jane Street, a U.S.-based proprietary trading firm, of using high-frequency trading strategies to manipulate index levels such as the Nifty 50 and Bank Nifty.

Sebi alleged that Jane Street pushed up index values in the morning by buying stocks and futures, only to reverse those trades later in the day, thereby influencing expiry-day pricing of options in its favour. The regulator said this allowed the firm to generate profits of over Rs 43,000 crore in index options, while deliberately incurring losses in the futures and equities segments.

Sebi has frozen Rs 4,843 crore in what it described as “unlawful gains” and barred Jane Street and its entities from accessing the Indian securities market until further notice.

Stock exchanges under scrutin

In its order, Sebi mentioned that stock exchanges had issued caution letters to Jane Street in the past. However, it remains unclear what further steps, if any, the exchanges took before Sebi stepped in with enforcement action.

Sharma’s remarks have drawn attention to this issue, especially since one of the two major exchanges—BSE—is a listed entity, while National Stock Exchange (NSE) remains unlisted but operates as a for-profit organisation.

The matter has sparked a broader debate about the role of exchanges in maintaining market integrity, particularly when sophisticated trading strategies and high-volume players are involved.

(Disclaimer: Recommendations, suggestions, views, and opinions given by the experts are their own. These do not represent the views of The Economic Times)



Source link

Visited 1 times, 1 visit(s) today

Related Article

Retail investors reap big gains from ‘buying the dip’ in US stocks

Retail investors reap big gains from ‘buying the dip’ in US stocks

Stay informed with free updates Simply sign up to the US equities myFT Digest — delivered directly to your inbox. Retail traders “buying the dip” in US stocks this year have racked up the biggest profits since the early stages of the Covid-19 crisis, helping to fuel a rally that has pushed Wall Street equities

ET logo

Jane Street aftermath: 4 stocks suffer Rs 12,000 crore wipeout in collateral damage

Markets regulator Sebi’s investigation into Jane Street may have unintended consequences for Dalal Street, as was evident on Friday when four capital market-related stocks collectively lost Rs 12,000 crore in market value. The regulatory action has exposed the market’s dependence on proprietary trading firms and their domestic partners. What began as targeted enforcement against alleged

How Everyday Investors Are Picking Stocks Without Wall Street Knowledge

How Everyday Investors Are Picking Stocks Without Wall Street Knowledge

Say goodbye to Excel spreadsheets, financial statements, and fancy Bloomberg terminals. Some everyday investors have a secret weapon that’s leading to winning stock picks. Bob Vanscoy bought Nvidia in 2020, years before the AI boom propelled the company to its current position as the world’s most valuable company. The 54-year-old father of two invested after

Person sitting at a desk working on a laptop.

2 Unstoppable Growth Stocks to Hold for the Next 20 Years

The stock market has an incredibly impressive long-term track record of wealth creation, and we can reasonably expect it to continue delivering excellent returns over the next 20 years. Investors can capitalize on this by buying ETFs that track major indexes, or by investing in individual stocks that can perform as well, if not better,

Person speaking to a smartphone.

Down Over 50%, Should You Buy the Dip on SoundHound AI Stock?

Shareholders of SoundHound AI (SOUN -1.42%) were riding high in 2024 after the stock posted an incredible 836% gain for the year. But 2025 is a different story. SoundHound stock is down 55% from the all-time high it reached late last year. The rise and fall of SoundHound stock has a common denominator: Nvidia. In

Paul Chan said funds raised in HK's IPOs ranked world 1st in first half year

Paul Chan said funds raised in HK’s IPOs ranked world 1st in first half year

發佈日期: 2025-07-06 12:00 TVB News 已複製連結 Financial Secretary Paul Chan said Hong Kong completed 42 initial public offerings in the first half of the year, , raising more than HK$107 billion, ranking first in the world. Paul Chan said in his blog that funds raised by initial public offerings in the first half of the

Buffett’s 1 test to spot a ‘satisfactory’ asset

Drew Angerer / Getty Images Moneywise and Yahoo Finance LLC may earn commission or revenue through links in the content below. The stock market has been on a roller coaster this year, as escalating trade tensions under President Donald Trump have rattled investor confidence. Many are worried about the fate of their finances. But investing

0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x