Hong Kong court quashes government decision to refuse permits to 2 Uber drivers

A Hong Kong court has quashed a government decision to refuse hire car permits to two prospective Uber drivers seven years ago, rejecting authorities’ contentions that the move could open the floodgates for ride-hailing services and private vehicles to operate as “pseudo-taxis”.

In a written judgment handed down on Thursday, the High Court found the Commissioner for Transport’s dismissal of two litigants’ requests for a permit in 2018 to be based on an “impracticable, illogical and unworkable” interpretation of the legal requirement that would likely render all first-time applications unsuccessful.

The court also dismissed the government’s argument that the legislature had only intended for taxis to provide personalised point-to-point journeys, ruling that it would effectively impose a categorical ban on ride-hailing operators and run contrary to authorities’ clear assurance that they would not be excluded from providing point-to-point services.

Mr Justice Russell Coleman ordered the Transport Tribunal to consider the matter afresh, but noted his ruling “would be practically determinative” of the applications for a permit in the applicants’ favour.

He stressed the judgment only concerned the correct interpretation of the law governing the issuance of hire car permits but not the government’s policy on e-hailing platforms.

The ruling came at a time when the government is mulling over legalising Uber and other ride-hailing services through the introduction of a regulatory framework amid popular demand and complaints against poor taxi services.

The litigants, Chen Hai-tao and Yin Wai-ho, jointly lodged a judicial review after failing to obtain a hire car permit that would have enabled them to legally work as Uber drivers using their Tesla Model S electric cars.

Source link

Visited 1 times, 1 visit(s) today

Hong Kong plans to update prison rules to better guard national security

Hong Kong’s security and prison agencies plan to update the current prison rules to tighten visiting criteria for specific lawyers, doctors and chaplains to ensure they safeguard national security, prevent crime and maintain order and discipline of those behind bars. In a paper submitted to the Legislative Council on Thursday, the Security Bureau and the

3 July 2025

150 live goats found, Hong Kong resident arrested in illegal slaughterhouse bust

A 51-year-old Hong Kong resident has been arrested for operating an illegal slaughterhouse in Yuen Long, where 150 live goats were discovered on a site with “extremely poor hygiene”. Authorities said the Food and Environmental Hygiene Department, in a joint operation with police on Thursday, raided a secluded, enclosed plot of land spanning Ngan Kam

3 July 2025

Hong Kong police arrest teenager who was alleged driver in fatal hit-and-run

Hong Kong police have apprehended a 19-year-old man in connection with a suspected hit-and-run accident that killed a 71-year-old man on a bicycle on Tuesday, the Post has learned. The arrest came a day after a couple, including a woman believed to be the suspect’s grandmother, were taken into custody. A source familiar with the

3 July 2025

Hong Kong water taxis, harbour cruise firm cash in on aircraft carrier’s visit

Some water transport operators are cashing in on the high-profile visit of the Chinese aircraft carrier Shandong and its strike fleet to Hong Kong by ferrying visitors for a better look, although marine police have stopped their vessels from getting close. Hong Kong Water Taxi, owned by the Oriental Pearl Cruise Company, organised special sightseeing

3 July 2025

The Hari Hong Kong Review

Stylish, confident, and welcoming, The Hari Hong Kong melds the commercial polish of nearby Causeway Bay with the creative energy and design-forward spirit of neighbouring Wan Chai. Rising 30 storeys above Lockhart Road, the hotel comprises 210 rooms and suites, including three expansive rooftop Signature Suites. Interiors are the work of celebrated British designer Tara

3 July 2025

Onlookers claim their spot as they look out for the Shandong at West Kowloon Cultural Area waterfront. Photo: Jelly Tse

From land to sea: top spots to get a glimpse of the Shandong in Hong Kong

Crowds of fans and onlookers gave an emotional welcome to the Chinese aircraft carrier Shandong and its accompanying strike group when they sailed into Hong Kong waters on Thursday for a five-day port call. Many are seeking alternatives or the best vantage points to view the fleet, as the Shandong is anchored to the west

3 July 2025

Symbolic Shandong visit: a sign of Hong Kong’s ‘rock-solid’ national security and pride

The arrival of the Chinese aircraft carrier Shandong, which represents “rock-solid” national security defence and high-quality development, would allow residents to witness first-hand the advancement of the mainland’s modernised military vessels, boosting national pride, Hong Kong’s leader has said. Speaking aboard the Shandong at a welcoming ceremony for the 70,000-tonne vessel and its accompanying strike

3 July 2025

Woo Guangdong visitors under cross-border scheme, Hong Kong transport chief says

A highly anticipated cross-border driving scheme for Guangdong residents will provide a boost for Hong Kong’s tourism-related industries, the transport chief has said, as she called on different sectors to offer a variety of tailored packages linked to hotels, restaurants and events to woo the new source of visitors. Secretary for Transport and Logistics Mable

3 July 2025

Hong Kong court quashes government decision to refuse permits to 2 Uber drivers

Related Article