Hong Kong court quashes government decision to refuse permits to 2 Uber drivers

A Hong Kong court has quashed a government decision to refuse hire car permits to two prospective Uber drivers seven years ago, rejecting authorities’ contentions that the move could open the floodgates for ride-hailing services and private vehicles to operate as “pseudo-taxis”.

In a written judgment handed down on Thursday, the High Court found the Commissioner for Transport’s dismissal of two litigants’ requests for a permit in 2018 to be based on an “impracticable, illogical and unworkable” interpretation of the legal requirement that would likely render all first-time applications unsuccessful.

The court also dismissed the government’s argument that the legislature had only intended for taxis to provide personalised point-to-point journeys, ruling that it would effectively impose a categorical ban on ride-hailing operators and run contrary to authorities’ clear assurance that they would not be excluded from providing point-to-point services.

Mr Justice Russell Coleman ordered the Transport Tribunal to consider the matter afresh, but noted his ruling “would be practically determinative” of the applications for a permit in the applicants’ favour.

He stressed the judgment only concerned the correct interpretation of the law governing the issuance of hire car permits but not the government’s policy on e-hailing platforms.

The ruling came at a time when the government is mulling over legalising Uber and other ride-hailing services through the introduction of a regulatory framework amid popular demand and complaints against poor taxi services.

The litigants, Chen Hai-tao and Yin Wai-ho, jointly lodged a judicial review after failing to obtain a hire car permit that would have enabled them to legally work as Uber drivers using their Tesla Model S electric cars.

Source link

Visited 1 times, 1 visit(s) today

Related Article

Hongkongers warned against consuming Oscar Mayer turkey bacon due to bacteria concerns

Hongkongers warned against consuming Oscar Mayer turkey bacon due to bacteria concerns

Health authorities have urged Hongkongers to avoid consuming certain batches of a pre-packaged turkey bacon product originating from the US due to possible bacterial contamination, after luxury supermarket chain City’super was found to have sold one. The Centre for Food Safety on Thursday night also called on the catering industry and retailers to immediately stop

4 July 2025
This illustration photograph taken on June 30, 2025 shows bitcoin representation coins against the backdrop of the Singapore national flag. Photo: AFP

Singapore’s crypto crackdown on unlicensed exchanges could drive liquidity to Hong Kong

Hong Kong could benefit from Singapore’s recent move to oust unlicensed cryptocurrency companies, according to analysts, potentially leading to a significant injection of liquidity. On May 30, the Monetary Authority of Singapore instructed cryptocurrency firms incorporated in the city and offering services abroad to acquire a licence or leave the country. Singapore’s central bank subsequently

4 July 2025
This illustration photograph taken on June 30, 2025 shows bitcoin representation coins against the backdrop of the Singapore national flag. Photo: AFP

Singapore’s crypto crackdown on unlicensed exchanges could drive liquidity to Hong Kong

Hong Kong could benefit from Singapore’s recent move to oust unlicensed cryptocurrency companies, according to analysts, potentially leading to a significant injection of liquidity. On May 30, the Monetary Authority of Singapore instructed cryptocurrency firms incorporated in the city and offering services abroad to acquire a licence or leave the country. Singapore’s central bank subsequently

4 July 2025
China’s Shandong aircraft carrier welcomes hundreds of eager guests in Hong Kong

China’s Shandong aircraft carrier welcomes hundreds of eager guests in Hong Kong

Hundreds of guests have embarked on a special tour of the Shandong in Hong Kong, getting a rare chance to explore the Chinese 70,000-tonne aircraft carrier and its fleet. China’s first home-grown aircraft carrier arrived in the city on Thursday for a five-day port call, accompanied by missile destroyers Yanan and Zhanjiang, and the missile

4 July 2025
The ceremonial gong used by the Hong Kong Exchanges and Clearing Limited (HKEX) to mark the commencement of trading of a new stock went on a citywide road show on June 20, 2025. Photo: Edmond So

Hong Kong’s bull market in stocks fills coffers, plugs hole left by property woes

Hong Kong’s stock market stamp duty income is filling the city’s financial coffers at the fastest pace since 2021, amid a bull run on the local bourse that has attracted scores of initial public offerings (IPOs) and fuelled frenzied trading. Duties from transactions and transfers rose to HK$29.69 billion (US$3.78 billion) in the first five

4 July 2025
Explainer | Heading to Japan? How Hongkongers can prepare amid earthquake concerns

Explainer | Heading to Japan? How Hongkongers can prepare amid earthquake concerns

Recent rumours about a “megaquake” hitting Japan on July 5, stemming from a manga artist whose earlier prediction in 2011 reportedly came true, have caused some concern among Hong Kong residents planning to travel to the country this month. While Japanese authorities have dismissed the claims, stating that earthquakes cannot be predicted with current scientific

4 July 2025
Hong Kong to issue No 1 typhoon signal at 12.20pm as tropical depression intensifies

Hong Kong to issue No 1 typhoon signal at 12.20pm as tropical depression intensifies

This story has been made freely available as a public service to our readers. Please consider supporting SCMP’s journalism by subscribing. New users who download our updated app get a seven-day free trial. Hong Kong’s weather forecaster will issue the No 1 typhoon warning signal at 12.20pm on Friday as a low pressure over the

4 July 2025
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x