Day Trading: Why Most Fail, What to Do Instead: Psychologist, Trading Coach

This as-told-to essay is based on a conversation with Andrew Menaker, a psychologist and a day trading coach based in San Francisco. It has been edited for length and clarity.

First of all, I had never, ever planned on becoming a trading psychology coach. In fact, many years ago, I never knew anything about markets. I think I had one econ class in undergrad. That was it.

I actually started my career at the US Navy as an independent psychological consultant. My job was to work with agencies like the NCIS, the FBI, and the Secret Service and to help with things like threat assessments and hostage negotiations. I felt like an impostor, coming right out of grad school, but I seemed to be a natural for it.

I got very lucky. Wells Fargo heard about my reputation in the Navy, and, after a post-doc internship with them, I was hired as a psychological consultant on their trading desk. Again, I felt like an impostor — no background in finance, brand new Ph.D. Here I am, green behind the ears. But the people at Wells Fargo saw something in me.

My very first clients were institutional desk traders who were moving hundreds of millions of dollars at the push of a button. It was the first time I had been exposed to trading.

After several years of consulting on Wall Street, I started trading on my own. It was the ’90s in San Francisco during the dot-com bubble. Stocks were starting to race up. The market bug bit, and I thought, “Oh my gosh, this is something for me. I’ve got to do this for myself.”


Photo of Andrew Menaker at his desk

Menaker now runs his own coaching practice where he works with traders on and off Wall Street.

Courtesy of Andrew Menaker



Back in those days, all stocks were going up, so it was kind of easy. My brokerage account went from $25,000 to $150,000 over a six-month period, and I was featured in a book about my trading success. I still trade today.

Now, I run my own coaching practice, where I work with traders of all sorts — Wall Street traders, prop traders, and even retail traders, some of whom are aiming to go full-time.

People usually come to me with some kind of trading issue: “I can’t follow my plan.” “I’m having a hard time accepting losses.” “I’m over-trading.”

What many people don’t realize is that they’re not just trading in a vacuum, whether they’re on a bank desk or in a hedge fund or trading their own money. Your whole life comes with you into every trade, whether you consciously realize it or not. My job is to help people understand that.

I call it trading your “inner market.” It’s comprised of biological influences — your sleep, your hormone levels — as well as your emotions — your thoughts, your memories, your experiences in life, how people see you, and how you want to be seen by others.

When a trader understands how their inner market operates, they start to see the market on the screen differently. By default, I end up becoming a life coach for many of my clients. I’m helping them, not just with their trading, but with marriages, divorces, having children, all kinds of stuff.

Here are some of the most common issues I see hold traders back — and what I recommend traders do instead.

Big ego

When I was featured in a book about my trading success, I was one of 16 top traders that was featured. That really puffed up my ego.

But within weeks of that book coming out, my trading went downhill. I had the biggest drawdown of my career.

I talk about this often with my clients. I call it the recognition trap. The fame and the pressure that comes with it can smell trouble for your performance, and that certainly happened to me.

Some of my clients might know that their ego is too big. But it often requires somebody else — someone credible that they trust — to actually point it out to them.

Too aggressive

Around 70%-80% of my retail clients are too aggressive in taking risks. They tend to put on too many trades. They tend to be impulsive. They can’t wait for the moment when their plan says they should be getting into the market.

And, when they lose money, they want to make it back as quickly as possible. So they start revenge trading, which usually makes things worse.

Too scared

There are some clients who are very frozen-deer-in-the-headlights. I see this often when I work with traders who are software engineers. Their background is all about precision, black and white, right or wrong. Unless it’s perfect, they’re not going to want to pull the trigger.

Well, markets are never perfect. They’re kind of messy. So people who tend to be more on the risk-averse side, they tend to be the under-traders.

Solutions

Journaling. All traders should be keeping what I call a real-time emotion journal. Ask yourself questions while you’re engaged with the market. What am I feeling right now? Why am I feeling this way? When I feel this way, what do I typically do? Write that out and answer it.

Many traders get pulled into the market. They’re staring at the screen and feel that they have no choice but to execute the trade. But you always have a choice. This type of reflection can help people recognize when they’re under pressure. They don’t have to hit the button so automatically.

Regulate your nervous system. When you’re feeling anxious, the limbic system will generate the flight, fight, or freeze response. We all have it. But that instinct often translates into hitting the button on your keyboard at the wrong time. If you can relax, the response won’t be quite as extreme.

You can downregulate your nervous system by tracking heart rate variability with a monitor. If you don’t have that, you can simply take slow, long breaths when you’re under pressure.

Be aware of your health. When I take on a new client, I explore their physiology with them. What’s your diet like? What’s your exercise routine? How much sleep are you getting? All of that filters into how we see the market and how we interact with it.

If you didn’t sleep much last night, be really careful about putting on trades. I’ve seen it with myself and my clients. There’s a correlation between sleep deprivation and sloppy trading.

Are you a day trader and want to share your story? Reach out to this reporter at jsor@businessinsider.com.



Source link

Visited 1 times, 1 visit(s) today

Related Article

What to know about Palantir's engineer-led sales strategy

Palantir stock slumps 9%, falling for a fifth straight day from record

CEO of Palantir Technologies Alex Karp attends the Pennsylvania Energy and Innovation Summit on the campus of Carnegie Mellon University in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania on July 15, 2025. Andrew Caballero-reynolds | Afp | Getty Images Palantir‘s stock slumped more than 9% on Tuesday, falling for a fifth straight day to continue its pullback from all-time highs.

Microsoft and Nvidia dip while Tesla and Walmart shine — TradingView News

Microsoft and Nvidia dip while Tesla and Walmart shine — TradingView News

Stock heatmap by FinViz.com Tue, 19 Aug 2025 14:46:08 GMT Sector Overview The tech sector faces challenges today, with major players experiencing declines. The heatmap depicts a troubling landscape for technology stocks, highlighting a particularly rough day for semiconductor and software players. Microsoft (MSFT) is down by 1.13%, and Nvidia (NVDA) sees a fall of 1.81%,

Warren Buffett Cashing in Stocks to Prepare for Slump: Paul Dietrich

Warren Buffett Cashing in Stocks to Prepare for Slump: Paul Dietrich

Warren Buffett may be cashing in stocks because he sees a storm on the horizon — and could buy them back once prices tumble, a senior market strategist says. The “Oracle of Omaha” has a “history of selling out of the stock market” when economic and financial indicators are “signaling a bear market or a

Crypto stocks tumble on Tuesday as investors go into risk-off mode

The Coinbase logo is displayed on a mobile phone screen with stock market percentages in the background. Idrees Abbas | Sopa Images | Lightrocket | Getty Images Crypto stocks suffered on Tuesday as investors fled tech stocks and riskier corners of the market. Among crypto exchanges, Coinbase and eToro fell more than 5% each, while

Another Prop Trading firm shut: Propel Capital

Another Prop Trading firm shut: Propel Capital

While the advent of retail prop trading is still very much on the rise, it has not been the case of a rising tide lifting all boats. Continuing a somewhat disturbing trend, another prop firm has shut its virtual doors, this time Propel Capital in the UK. Mitchell Ali Founded just over a year ago

EUR/USD Analysis 19/08: Peace Talks and Fed Loom (Chart)

Peace Talks and Fed Loom (Chart)

Created on August 19, 2025 EUR/USD Analysis Summary Today Overall Trend: Neutral with an upward bias. Support Levels Today: 1.1640 – 1.1560 – 1.1490. Resistance Levels Today: 1.1720 – 1.1800 – 1.1880. EUR/USD Trading Signals: Buy EUR/USD from the 1.1580 support level, with a target of 1.1800 and a stop-loss at 1.1500. Sell EUR/USD from

ET logo

Dow S&P 500 Nasdaq rally today: US stocks reverse gains: Dow climbs, S&P steadies, Nasdaq slips—what’s pushing the market rally now?

The US stock market wavered on Tuesday as investors weighed stronger-than-expected housing starts against a pullback in building permits, highlighting a still-uneven outlook for the real estate sector. The Dow Jones Industrial Average managed modest gains, lifted by industrial and retail names, while the S&P 500 and Nasdaq slipped under pressure from tech. Bucking the

Natural Gas Forecast 19/08: Market Weakness Persists (Video)

Natural Gas Forecast 19/08: Market Weakness Persists (Video)

Created on August 19, 2025 The natural gas market is pretty noisy during the trading session here on Monday, initially dropping, but then turning around at this point. I think what we’re trying to do, some of you technical analysts out there might look at this as a potential liquidity grab. That’s not what it