Boston judge rules Trump-era deportations violated First Amendment rights

Boston judge rules Trump-era deportations violated First Amendment rights

In a 161-page decision released Tuesday out of Federal Court in Boston, U.S. District Court Judge William Young says the Trump Administration has been abusing its power when it comes to First Amendment rights of non-citizens.

“He actually says this is the most important case he’s seen in 47 years, and I can see why,” said Matt Cameron, an immigration attorney in Boston.

“We are not, and we must not become, a nation that imprisons and deports people because we are afraid of what they have to tell us,” said Judge Young in his ruling Tuesday.

Attorney Matt Cameron says the ruling Tuesday is huge for the First Amendment rights of immigrant students who have been targeted for showing support for Palestine.

“I really think this is an incredible vindication of those rights, it’s really encouraging to see a judge come out like this,” said Cameron.

Judge Young focused a big part of his decision on the case of Rumeysa Ozturk, the Tufts University Grad student who was arrested by ICE agents in Somerville in March.

“I think it’s very important in this country that everyone understands they have the right to write an editorial and go home safely and not be arrested in the street by masked agents of the government,” said Cameron.

Ozturk was held in an ICE detention center for six weeks for an op-ed article she co-authored at Tufts on the war in Gaza.

Even though she has been released, her case was brought back to court in New York Tuesday as the government pushes for her detainment.

Ozturk’s lawyers say the ruling out of Boston is promising for her case after the judge said: “the effect of these targeted deportation proceedings continues unconstitutionally to chill freedom of speech to this day.”

“It’s a very important takeaway and just to really emphasize and underscore just how unusual these arrests are, how strange this moment is and how completely un-American so much of what we’re seeing right now is in the broader historical sense,” said Cameron. “To have a judge say it that clearly, I really think this is a decision that’s meant to be read by everybody, and it should be.”

Following his ruling Tuesday, Judge Young says there will be a hearing on remedy, which means the Court will find a solution on how the government can move forward in cases like this.

Judge Young was appointed by Republican President Ronald Reagan, and he has been on the bench for nearly 50 years.

This is a developing story. Check back for updates as more information becomes available.

Download the FREE Boston 25 News app for breaking news alerts.

Follow Boston 25 News on Facebook and Twitter. | Watch Boston 25 News NOW



Source link

Visited 1 times, 1 visit(s) today

Related Article

Pentagon spokesman Sean Parnell announced the Iraq troop reduction in a statement.(REUTERS File)

US, allies winding down anti-ISIS mission in Iraq, reducing forces

Published on: Oct 01, 2025 08:43 pm IST Washington and Baghdad agreed last year that the international coalition against IS would end its military mission in Iraq by the end of September 2025. US and allied forces are reducing their presence in Iraq, the Pentagon said Wednesday, winding down a more than decade-long mission there

5 Steps You Must Take To Be in the Top 1% in Your 50s

By the time you reach the age of 50, you should have already made a multitude of financial decisions (along with years of planning) to ensure your economic comfort and freedom in the decade leading up to your retirement and golden years. Check Out: How Much You Need To Earn To Be Upper Middle Class

Drones target German ports, hospitals and oil refineries in latest hybrid attack

Drones target German ports, hospitals and oil refineries in latest hybrid attack

Germany is investigating Russia’s involvement in a mysterious swarm of drones spying on a power plant, hospital and military shipyard. A fuel refinery and a regional parliament were also targeted in what could be the latest example of Moscow’s hybrid war against Nato. The unmanned aerial vehicles were spotted flying over the facilities in Schleswig-Holstein,

Maxine Waters Snaps at Pro-MAGA Reporter on Capitol Steps

Maxine Waters Snaps at Pro-MAGA Reporter on Capitol Steps

Screenshot via LindellTV Rep. Maxine Waters (D-CA) snapped at a reporter confronting her on the government shutdown and whether Democrats are fighting for “healthcare for illegal immigrants.” Waters was confronted outside the Capitol on Tuesday by LindellTV reporter Alison Steinberg. LindellTV was founded by Mike Lindell, a 2024 election conspiracy theorist who has long been

Seven men jailed in UK for total of 174 years

Seven men jailed in UK for total of 174 years

LONDON, – Seven men who sexually exploited two vulnerable girls in northern England were jailed on Wednesday for a total of 174 years, after they were convicted following the latest trial over a decades-old “grooming gangs” scandal. Seven men jailed in UK for total of 174 years The men were convicted in June after a

An exterior rendering shows the Bradford Live restored and reborn as a cornerstone of Bradford arts and entertainment.

Local support rescues century-old U.K. performance hall from demolition

Like so many buildings of the early 20th century left abandoned, the 3,300-seat New Victoria performance hall in Bradford in West Yorkshire, U.K., could have been demolished. Its spectacular interior architecture, featuring soaring vaulted ceilings, would have been forgotten. Instead, it has been saved and restored to its former glory. New Victoria opened in 1928

IDF soldiers operate in Gaza City, September 17, 2025. (credit: IDF SPOKESPERSON'S UNIT)

Hamas terrorist disguised as hostage attempts to kidnap IDF soldiers in Gaza

During operations in the Gaza Strip, soldiers took notice of a figure waving a white flag in their direction and calling for help. A Hamas terrorist disguised as a hostage attempted to lure IDF soldiers away into a possible trap on Monday night, N12 reported on Tuesday, citing the IDF Spokesperson’s Unit. During operations in