MPs demand chief prosecutor explain China spy case collapse

Paul SeddonPolitical reporter

PA Media Director of Public Prosecutions Stephen Parkinson, pictured sitting behind a desk in his officePA Media

Stephen Parkinson has been criticial of Sir Keir Starmer’s time as head of the CPS

The director of public prosecutions is facing mounting pressure to further explain the collapse of a case against two men accused of spying for China.

MPs are demanding Stephen Parkinson give a “fuller explanation” of why charges against parliamentary researcher Christopher Cash, 30, and academic Christopher Berry, 33, were dropped last month. Both men deny the allegations.

Parkinson has blamed the collapse of the case on a failure by the government to provide enough evidence showing China was a threat to the UK’s national security.

But calls for clarification have grown after the government published witness statements on Wednesday outlining the threat posed by Beijing.

The chairs of four parliamentary committees have given Mr Parkinson, the boss of the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS), until Friday next week to answer a series of questions about why the case collapsed.

He is also likely to hauled before MPs to give evidence, with a joint national security committee of MPs and peers also launching a formal inquiry.

Labour MP Matt Western, who chairs the committee, said there were “many questions yet to be answered” by both Mr Parkinson and the government.

Western added that the committee would hope to hear from “the government and officials” as soon as possible.

Another parliamentary group, the intelligence and security committee, has launched a separate probe into how classified material was used during the case.

Witness statements

Mr Cash and Mr Berry were charged last year under the 1911 Official Secrets Act, accused of gathering and providing information prejudicial to the safety and interests of the state between December 2021 and February 2023.

This legislation requires prosecutors to prove that suspects have passed on material that could be “directly or indirectly useful to an enemy”.

In a letter to MPs last week, Mr Parkinson said a court ruling in a separate case following the charges meant this included countries deemed to pose a “threat to the national security of the UK” at the time of the alleged offences.

He added that CPS lawyers had dropped the case after failing to obtain sufficient evidence from the government describing China to this effect.

It prompted a row with ministers, with Sir Keir Starmer saying he was “deeply disappointed” the prosecutions did not go ahead and taking the unusual step of publishing government witness statements given to the CPS.

The three statements, written by deputy national security adviser Matthew Collins, are clear that the Chinese are carrying out spying operations against the UK.

In the documents, he said China was carrying out “large scale espionage” against the UK and was “the biggest state-based threat to the country’s economic security”.

Criticism of Starmer

Mr Parkinson met senior MPs on Wednesday, and is reported to have told them the government’s evidence fell “5%” short of what would have been required to stand a chance of getting a conviction.

But some MPs have continued to question why the CPS did not deem it had enough evidence to continue the case.

It has thrust Mr Parkinson, who was appointed director of public prosecutions in September 2023 under the previous Conservative government, into the heart of an abnormally public row with ministers.

The episode is especially unusual because Mr Parkinson is himself a successor to Sir Keir, with the prime minister having led the CPS between 2013 and 2018, before he first entered Parliament two years later.

A former senior partner at law firm Kingsley Napley, Parkinson initially trained as a barrister before switching to become a solicitor in 2005.

Before his appointment as director of public prosecutions, he had been critical of Sir Keir’s own time in the role, describing the now-prime minister as “an average DPP” in a May 2023 interview with The Times.

He was quoted as saying the Labour leader “was over-reliant on advice given by others; he had no in-depth experience of prosecuting… he was a defence and human rights lawyer”.

In an interview in April, Mr Parkinson described how he had initially not applied to university due to poor predicted grades, before deciding to reconsider after his actual results turned out to be better than expected.

He took a year out to apply to study law, during which he worked as a dustman, on a kibbutz and as a ballpoint pen salesman in South Africa.

Source link

Visited 4 times, 4 visit(s) today

Related Article

Lithium battery catches fire during Air China flight

Lithium battery catches fire during Air China flight

IE 11 is not supported. For an optimal experience visit our site on another browser. Now Playing Lithium battery catches fire during Air China flight 00:12 UP NEXT ‘No Kings’ protest kicks off in Washington 00:30 Officer pulls woman from a burning car in Texas 00:21 Swifties raise $2 million for Monterey Bay Aquarium 00:28

Krislyn Massey wears a cowboy hat to show off her Texas pride at Xian Jiaotong-Liverpool University in Suzhou, China. Photo: Krislyn Massey

In Texas, a student trip to China becomes a political act

For Krislyn Massey, it all began with late nights watching Japanese anime as a child. That sparked a discovery of Chinese novels and a deep interest in studying Asia – an unlikely path for someone who grew up in a conservative family in Houston, Texas. She began learning Japanese and getting involved in student-run educational

China introduces new cross-border data transfer rules, effective January 2026

China introduces new cross-border data transfer rules, effective January 2026

Chinese regulators released new requirements this week for certifying cross-border transfers of personal information. The rules require “non-critical information infrastructure operators” to obtain certifications before transferring certain data across borders.The framework aims to protect personal information rights and facilitate secure cross-border data flows, according to statements from China’s cyberspace and market regulators, news agency Reuters

Friend or foe? The China challenge on the Moray Firth

Friend or foe? The China challenge on the Moray Firth

Douglas FraserBusiness/economy editor, Scotland Getty Images The offer from Ming Yang would see parts built for wind turbines Accepting the offer to build parts for wind turbines looks like a no-brainer. About £1.5bn of investment, 1500 jobs – perhaps even double that – and at last, a sign that the renewables energy bonanza is going

Top US and China envoys set trade talks after ‘constructive’ video call

Top US and China envoys set trade talks after ‘constructive’ video call

Chinese Vice-Premier He Lifeng and US Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent held a video call on Saturday morning and stated that trade negotiators from their countries would meet next week. “This evening, Vice-Premier He Lifeng and I engaged in frank and detailed discussions regarding trade between the United States and China,” Bessent wrote on social media

Passengers aboard the Air China flight on Saturday were heard yelling “hurry up” in Korean. Photo: Handout

Battery fire aboard Air China flight to South Korea forces emergency landing

An Air China flight from Hangzhou to Seoul was forced to make an emergency landing in Shanghai on Saturday after a lithium battery caught fire in the plane’s cabin. In a statement on social media, Air China confirmed the incident. “On October 18, on flight CA139 from Hangzhou to Incheon, a lithium battery in a

A man looks to his right and above him is the roof of a hall dotted with white lights circling a red star.

Chinese Communist Party’s Central Committee set for major shake-up at plenum meeting

A key Chinese Communist Party (CCP) meeting next week to decide a strategic plan is expected to include a major shake-up of President Xi Jinping’s inner circle.  Analysts expect a record political purge at the four-day plenum meeting of the CCP’s 205-member Central Committee that starts in Beijing on Monday.  The meeting is to flesh