Legal Tales | A brief history of pupil barristers and the system’s evolution in Hong Kong

On the first day of my pupillage in September 1999, my “pupil master” showed me around his chambers and introduced me to various members. Not being alive to our customs and traditions, I put my hand out expecting a firm handshake with a senior member but was told: “You are now a member of the Bar and we do not shake hands with each other.”

It was then explained to me that the tradition was rooted in the sword-bearing era, when a handshake signalled no hostile intent and was unnecessary for a gentleman’s profession.

What followed for me was 12 months as “the lowest form of legal life”, which was most enjoyable and challenging.

It was challenging for me to discover how little I knew, but it was probably more challenging for my pupil masters, who had to deal with the shock of discovering how little I knew. One of them commented that it was easier to teach a piece of char siu (Cantonese barbecue pork) than to teach me. I am still not entirely sure it was meant to be a joke, but I have convinced myself that it was.

The routine of being cross-examined by them on my work and my inability to come up with anything coherent in response continued for the next 12 months.

To my horror, that began to happen again a few years later when one of my pupil masters joined the bench (i.e. became a judge). My inability to deal with questions from him has become a recurring feature of my day-to-day life when appearing before him in court.

Source link

Visited 1 times, 1 visit(s) today

Related Article

Hong Kong warns against unapproved yuan stablecoins amid crypto frenzy

Hong Kong warns against unapproved yuan stablecoins amid crypto frenzy

The Hong Kong Monetary Authority (HKMA) cautioned investors that no stablecoins pegged to the offshore yuan had been approved for issuance in the city, as regulators sought to temper the frenzy surrounding digital assets. In a statement published on WeChat on Wednesday, the HKMA refuted claims circulating on social media that the first offshore yuan-pegged

Hong Kong rules out pre-made restaurant meal labelling despite consumer concern

Hong Kong rules out pre-made restaurant meal labelling despite consumer concern

Hong Kong authorities have ruled out the possibility of requiring labelling for pre-cooked meals at restaurants, citing the absence of uniform standards and varying interpretations of the concept. Secretary for Environment and Ecology Tse Chin-wan told lawmakers on Thursday that the government would continue to develop standards and certifications for prepared dishes to support the

A wave sweeps the man on the bench off his feet during Ragasa. Photo: Elson Li

Post photographer hopes viral Ragasa man-on-bench image warns against danger

Post photographer Elson Li did not expect to see anyone when he arrived at the Tseung Kwan O promenade, where raging waves were crashing into the coast as Super Typhoon Ragasa reached its closest point to Hong Kong. But a man sitting alone on a bench facing the sea, with the Tseung Kwan O Cross

Residents watch as waves pound the Siu Sai Wan waterfront during Super Typhoon Ragasa. Photo: Karma Lo

Hong Kong aims to curb storm chasing after mother and son hospitalised during Ragasa

Hong Kong’s security minister will consider new legislation to curb storm chasing after a woman and her five-year-old son were left hospitalised in intensive care by a strong wave sweeping them into the sea during the No 8 signal for Super Typhoon Ragasa. Secretary for Security Chris Tang Ping-keung also warned on Thursday that bringing

Hong Kong cancels all typhoon warning signals as Ragasa moves away

Hong Kong cancels all typhoon warning signals as Ragasa moves away

This story has been made freely available as a public service to our readers. Please consider supporting SCMP’s journalism by subscribing now for 50 per cent off during our two-day flash sale. Hong Kong’s weather forecaster has cancelled all typhoon warning signals as Tropical Storm Ragasa continues to move away after wreaking havoc in the

Hong Kong stocks waver amid profit-taking after tech-led rally a day earlier

Hong Kong stocks waver amid profit-taking after tech-led rally a day earlier

Hong Kong stocks fluctuated on Thursday as investors took profit following a strong rally fuelled by technology stocks a day earlier. The Hang Seng Index was little changed at 26,517.46 as of 9.45am. The Hang Seng Tech Index gained 0.3 per cent. On the mainland, the CSI 300 Index and the Shanghai Composite Index both

Geely drone subsidiary Aerofugia eyes Hong Kong market for AE200 flying car

Geely drone subsidiary Aerofugia eyes Hong Kong market for AE200 flying car

A mainland Chinese drone manufacturer owned by a carmaking giant has revealed that it is eyeing Hong Kong as a future market for its flagship passenger-carrying flying car, as the city embarks on a new phase of developing its low-altitude economy. Aerofugia, a subsidiary of China’s second-largest carmaker, Zhejiang Geely Holding Group, said that Hong

Opinion | Why Hong Kong must seize opening of Trump’s H-1B visa chaos

Opinion | Why Hong Kong must seize opening of Trump’s H-1B visa chaos

The US’ shake-up of its H-1B visa programme has left businesses scrambling to respond. On September 19, President Donald Trump announced that companies hiring foreign nationals to work in the United States under the scheme would be charged an extra US$100,000 per beneficiary, effective from September 21. The vague language of the proclamation created widespread