Hong Kong court quashes government decision to refuse permits to 2 Uber drivers

A Hong Kong court has quashed a government decision to refuse hire car permits to two prospective Uber drivers seven years ago, rejecting authorities’ contentions that the move could open the floodgates for ride-hailing services and private vehicles to operate as “pseudo-taxis”.

In a written judgment handed down on Thursday, the High Court found the Commissioner for Transport’s dismissal of two litigants’ requests for a permit in 2018 to be based on an “impracticable, illogical and unworkable” interpretation of the legal requirement that would likely render all first-time applications unsuccessful.

The court also dismissed the government’s argument that the legislature had only intended for taxis to provide personalised point-to-point journeys, ruling that it would effectively impose a categorical ban on ride-hailing operators and run contrary to authorities’ clear assurance that they would not be excluded from providing point-to-point services.

Mr Justice Russell Coleman ordered the Transport Tribunal to consider the matter afresh, but noted his ruling “would be practically determinative” of the applications for a permit in the applicants’ favour.

He stressed the judgment only concerned the correct interpretation of the law governing the issuance of hire car permits but not the government’s policy on e-hailing platforms.

The ruling came at a time when the government is mulling over legalising Uber and other ride-hailing services through the introduction of a regulatory framework amid popular demand and complaints against poor taxi services.

The litigants, Chen Hai-tao and Yin Wai-ho, jointly lodged a judicial review after failing to obtain a hire car permit that would have enabled them to legally work as Uber drivers using their Tesla Model S electric cars.

Source link

Visited 1 times, 1 visit(s) today

Related Article

Is proposal to recognise same-sex partnerships in Hong Kong dead on arrival?

Is proposal to recognise same-sex partnerships in Hong Kong dead on arrival?

A proposal by the Hong Kong government to recognise same-sex partnerships in line with a top court ruling may hit a dead end amid mounting opposition in the legislature, with one legal expert saying authorities may consider a rejection as closing the file on the controversy. Failure to enact the legislation could mean that same-sex

More than 90% of Hong Kong’s AI supercomputing capacity in use, Cyberport says

More than 90% of Hong Kong’s AI supercomputing capacity in use, Cyberport says

Hong Kong’s ambition to create an artificial intelligence (AI) ecosystem is bearing fruit, with more than 90 per cent of the city’s flagship supercomputing centre at Cyberport now in use, according to officials. The AI Supercomputing Centre, which began operations in December, is a cornerstone of the government’s strategy to foster a vibrant local AI

Leading Hong Kong forensic pathologist Philip Beh dies after battle with cancer

Leading Hong Kong forensic pathologist Philip Beh dies after battle with cancer

Leading Hong Kong forensic pathologist Dr Philip Beh Swan-lip, who dedicated his career to helping families that had lost loved ones find closure and co-founded the city’s first sexual violence crisis centre, has died. Beh was also involved in a high-profile inquest into the death of a 15-year-old girl whose naked body was found at

The ceremonial gong used by the Hong Kong Exchanges and Clearing Limited (HKEX) to mark the commencement of trading of a new stock went on a citywide road show on June 20, 2025. Photo: Edmond So

Hong Kong’s bull market in stocks fills coffers, plugs hole left by property woes

Hong Kong’s stock market stamp duty income is filling the city’s financial coffers at the fastest pace since 2021, amid a bull run on the local bourse that has attracted scores of initial public offerings (IPOs) and fuelled frenzied trading. Duties from transactions and transfers rose to HK$29.69 billion (US$3.78 billion) in the first five

How is China using Shandong’s visit to Hong Kong to boost patriotism, reflect power?

How is China using Shandong’s visit to Hong Kong to boost patriotism, reflect power?

As Hong Kong celebrates the 28th anniversary of its return to Chinese rule, Beijing has once again deployed a powerful naval fleet, this time spearheaded by the aircraft carrier Shandong, highlighting both symbolic significance and strategic resolve amid escalating geopolitical tensions. China’s first domestically built aircraft carrier and its fleet arrived in Hong Kong on

Hong Kong China Aircraft Carrier

China’s first homemade aircraft carrier sails into Hong Kong in a show of military prowess

HONG KONG — China’s first domestically-built aircraft carrier led a naval fleet into Hong Kong waters this week in a show of national pride that underlined Beijing’s growing military force and ambitions. Shandong, escorted by three other homemade warships, kicked off a five-day stop in the semi-autonomous Chinese territory on Thursday. Shandong is named after

0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x